Sunset Beach

Shelter Island, New York

Sunset Beach is a hotel located in Shelter Island.

A romantic seaside hideaway nestled on the sands of Shelter Island on the eastern end of Long Island, New York.

Local dining options close to Sunset Beach include Jennie’s At Drossos, Porto Bello, Pepi's Cucina Di Casa, and A Lure Restaurant Chowder House & Oysteria.

Sunset Beach

35 Shore Road
Shelter Island, New York, 11965 USA

Tel: (631) 749-2001

The information displayed here is displayed 'as is' and was last updated on June 28th, 2022. Check the website ( if listed ) for up-to-date information, prices and availability. Where To Stay USA is not responsible for the content of external websites. If you are the owner or operator of Sunset Beach and wish to update or modify the content on this page including room details, specials and getaways or availability, please use our submission page.

Please note map locations may based on either the address, the town or based on the location of the listed properties zip / postcode.

Quick navigate Shelter Island Hotels

Pridwin Hotel & Cottages

West Neck Guesthouse

Sunset Beach reviews

Enter your comments about your experience at Sunset Beach in Shelter Island, New York. Please do not include requests for booking or reservation information or ask for other contact details in relations to the property owners. Any such requests will be removed from the review system.

Date of stay:

On a scale of 1-10 how would you rate your OVERALL experience:

Rate 10 for best, 1 for worst

Rate the LOCATION:

Rate 10 for best, 1 for worst

Rate the VALUE FOR MONEY:

Rate 10 for best, 1 for worst

Rate the STAFF / SERVICE:

Rate 10 for best, 1 for worst

Rate the CLEANLINESS:

Rate 10 for best, 1 for worst

Describe your general experience at this property.

Please read our guidelines before submitting.

List any POSITIVES:

List any NEGATIVES:

Select a username

Enter your email address*

I certify that this review is my genuine opinion of this property, and that I have no personal or business affiliation with this establishment, and have not been offered any incentive or payment originating from the establishment or a competitor to write this review. I also certify that this review complies with the guidelines below.

* Your email will not be published, used for marketing purposes or revealed to anyone affiliated with the property concerned.

Guidelines:

Comments about this accommodation may be edited for content, and can take up to 24 hours to appear.

Reviews containing any of the following will not be posted:

Profanity or threats
Personal insults
Reports of violent criminal activity
Commercial web addresses, e-mail addresses or phone numbers
Text entirely in ALL CAPS
Hearsay
Content not relevant to tourists
HTML

If you are a representative of this property and wish to respond to a review, you can use this form, however, you may be contacted to verify your identity.

Any prices displayed for Sunset Beach should be used as a guide only and may vary with room and dates chosen. Lower pricing may be available via the booking system if available. Not all properties are available for online booking. Please note all distances shown are approximate, and may not reflect driving or travel distances.

New York | Manhattan | Lake George | Brooklyn | Cooperstown