Rodeway Inn

Reviewer: Not provided on Tue 21 Dec 2010 rated 9 out of 10.

This is a typical moderate priced roadside hotel which met all our expectations. Our room was large, beds were comfortable, wifi access was excellent, bath facilities clean and we had good hot running water in the shower. A perfect stopover with no frills. The hotel is conveniently located within 2 miles of all shops in downtown New Paltz. Also, easy access to NYS Thruway.

Positives: All amenities for a moderate priced hotel were excellent. Location good, room was clean & large, bed comfortable and excellent wifi.

Negatives: The hotel should restrict access to building for hotel guests only.

Reviewer: Not provided on Mon 27 Sep 2010 rated 2 out of 10.

I would not recommend this hotel to anyone. We stayed here for a family wedding for one night and it was more than enough, if we could have gone elsewhere we would have. The staff was rude and the water from the facet was brown. Our room was located outside of the main building and very noisy due to people chatting outside their room. The carpet looked like it need a real vacuuming and continental breakfast was a joke.

Positives: Nothing.

Negatives: Everything.

Reviewer: Not provided on Thu 31 Dec 2009 rated 8 out of 10.

It is suitable enough for family purposes, and is totally remodeled from its previous incarnation. Its location is perhaps a bit removed from areas that most people like to visit.

Positives: Economical

Negatives: No desk or table in the room. Ice machine in a public area flooded the hallway.

Reviewer: Not provided on Wed 16 Jan 2008 rated 1 out of 10.

The worst would not recommend for a dog to stay in. what a dump.

Positives: Checking out!

Negatives: Checking in, and staying.

Reviewer: Not provided on Tue 17 Jul 2007 rated 6 out of 10.

This hotel was quiet and convenient but our nonsmoking room smelled like smoke. Even the chairs had burn holes in them. When we questioned if it was a nonsmoking room, we were told it was. The staff told us we smelled the smoke from the room next to us.

Positives: It was quiet and convenient.

Negatives: Our nonsmoking room, smelled like smoke.

Reviewer: Not provided on Wed 24 Jan 2007 rated 4 out of 10.

If this hotel wasn't a good price, it wouldn't be one you'd want to stay at. It was dirty, and the "renovations" looked like they were about 5 years old and done badly.

Positives: High speed internet access.

Negatives: Dirty, broken heater, poor repair.

Reviewer: Not provided on Wed 01 Nov 2006 rated 4 out of 10.

I would not desire to return to this hotel after having plumbing back ups on two consecutive days. The room was dark and a bit gloomy. The tile had mold.

Positives: Staff was gracious.

Negatives: Plumbing backed up, no remote for TV, burned out lights, dark room.

Reviewer: Not provided on Thu 29 Jun 2006 rated 9 out of 10.

Very clean and comfortable, ok with late check-in, no one available for early check-out. Would stay again when back in area.

Positives: Very clean and quiet.

Negatives: Bathroom light needed repair (short).

Reviewer: Not provided on Sun 21 Aug 2005 rated 10 out of 10.

WOW ... what a stay. Simply put, the best aspects of this property were value and comfortability. The property is very relaxing and quiet. The brand new suites are very comfortable, and encourage a homey feeling. The staff was very helpful in guiding myself and my family throughout the town while we were there. I have stayed at the other properties in New Paltz, and let me tell you they are not in comparison to this property. And to top it all off, the rates are very competitve. I recommend this hotel to any traveller to New Paltz, PS upgrade to the suite!

Positives: Excellent amenities, and excellent price!

Negatives: the hotel was single story - I've always enjoyed the top floor