Hotels, Motels, Inns, B&B's, Resorts And Extended Stay in Shelter Island, New York

There are 7 properties listed under Hotels, Motels and Extended Stay Suites in Shelter Island available. All distances are from the center of Shelter Island, so actual travel times may vary.

Candlelite Inn & Guest House

Hotel

Located 1 mile from the center of Shelter Island. The Candlelite Inn is a 181 year old Victorian, situated on one and a half acres in the center of Shelter Island.

3 South Ferry Road

Shelter Island, New York

Sunset Beach

Hotel

Located 2 miles from the center of Shelter Island. A romantic seaside hideaway nestled on the sands of Shelter Island on the eastern end of Long Island, New York..

35 Shore Road

Shelter Island, New York

Pridwin Hotel & Cottages

Hotel

Located 2 miles from the center of Shelter Island. Where you can exchange your hectic day-to-day pace for all the joys of beachside life.

81 Shore Road

Shelter Island, New York

Dering Harbor Inn

Hotel

Located 2 miles from the center of Shelter Island. The inn offers individually appointed, fully furnished one- and two-bedroom suites and villas, each with private balcony, ideal for both short- and long-term stays..

13 Winthrop Road

Shelter Island, New York

West Neck Guesthouse

Bed & Breakfast

31 West Neck Road

Shelter Island, New York