Places to stay in Shelter Island, New York

Shelter Island is a town at the eastern end of Long Island in New York. It forms the tip of Suffolk County and is separated from the rest of the county by water. Local dining options include Noah's, Greenport Crab & Seafood Co, North Fork Oyster Company, and Meson Ole!.

If you are travelling in the area, Shelter Island is located close to Village of North Haven, Calf Creek, Lenz Vineyards, Crab Creek and Sag Harbor Elementary School.

The center of Shelter Island ( which is at is longitude -72°19'10.92 and latitude 41°3'36.36 ) is located 2 miles away from Shelter Island Heights, 5 miles away from Greenport, 5 miles away from Sag Harbor and 5 miles away from East Marion.

Available Shelter Island lodging

We currently have 8 accommodations in and around Shelter Island.

Shelter Island Hotels, Motels, Resorts, B&Bs and Extended Stay

Hotels

Candlelite Inn & Guest House

The Candlelite Inn is a 181 year old Victorian, situated on one and a half acres in the center of Shelter Island.

3 South Ferry Road

Shelter Island, New York

Hotels

Dering Harbor Inn

The inn offers individually appointed, fully furnished one- and two-bedroom suites and villas, each with private balcony, ideal for both short- and long-term stays..

13 Winthrop Road

Shelter Island, New York