Places to stay in Highland Lake, New York

Highland Lake is a hamlet in Sullivan County, New York. The community is 12.4 miles (20.0 km) southwest of Monticello. Highland Lake has a post office with ZIP code 12743, which opened on June 18, 1897. Local restaurants include CrossRoads Restaurant, Il Castello, and Tre Alberi Ristorante & Motel.

If you are travelling in the area, Highland Lake is located close to Gabriel Lake, Long Swamp, Sacred Heart Church, Township of Westfall and West Branch Mongaup River.

The center of Highland Lake ( which is at is longitude -74°50'57.706 and latitude 41°31'17.601 ) is located 2 miles away from Eldred, 5 miles away from Barryville and 9 miles away from Forestburgh.

Available Highland Lake lodging

We currently have 6 accommodations in and around Highland Lake.

Highland Lake Hotels, Motels, Resorts, B&Bs and Extended Stay

Hotels

Eldred Preserve Resort

Approx 4 miles away in Eldred:

The Eldred Preserve project being brought to life by local resident and entrepreneur Dan Silna and his wife, Joan, is a wholly unique concept that weaves the very best of three Sullivan County legacy brands – The Eldred Preserve, The Bradstan .....

1040 Route 55

Eldred, New York

Hotels

Washington Lake Retreat

Approx 5 miles away in Yulan:

172 Airport Road

Yulan, New York

Bed & Breakfasts

Mountain View Resort

Approx 5 miles away in Glen Spey:

369 High Road

Glen Spey, New York

Highland Lake Camping & RV, Cottages, Rentals and Lodges / Ranches

Photograph of Koinonia Family Camp, Highland Lake

Listing updated 2026

Campsite / RV Parks

Koinonia Family Camp

Koinonia is a place to experience joy, peace, beauty, the richness of faith-filled community and a chance to discover life anew. Grounded in the Lutheran understanding of Christian faith, Koinonia welcomes everyone..

165 Lakeview Drive Road

Highland Lake, New York

Cottages

Mohican Lake Resort

Approx 3 miles away in Glen Spey:

97 Leers Road

Glen Spey, New York

Cottages

Blue Heron Lakehouse

Approx 4 miles away in Yulan:

62 Washington Lake Road

Yulan, New York

Booking.com