Places to stay in Highland Lake, New York

Highland Lake is a hamlet in Sullivan County, New York. The community is 12.4 miles (20.0 km) southwest of Monticello. Highland Lake has a post office with ZIP code 12743, which opened on June 18, 1897. Local restaurants include CrossRoads Restaurant, Il Castello, and Tre Alberi Ristorante & Motel.

If you are travelling in the area, Highland Lake is located close to Shohola Elementary School, White Lake Church, Sap Brook, Lava Cemetery and Tink Hill.

The center of Highland Lake ( which is at is longitude -74°50'57.706 and latitude 41°31'17.601 ) is located 2 miles away from Eldred, 5 miles away from Barryville and 9 miles away from Forestburgh.

Available Highland Lake lodging

We currently have 6 accommodations in and around Highland Lake.

Highland Lake Hotels, Motels, Resorts, B&Bs and Extended Stay

Hotels

Eldred Preserve Resort

Approx 4 miles away in Eldred:

The Eldred Preserve project being brought to life by local resident and entrepreneur Dan Silna and his wife, Joan, is a wholly unique concept that weaves the very best of three Sullivan County legacy brands – The Eldred Preserve, The Bradstan .....

1040 Route 55

Eldred, New York

Hotels

Washington Lake Retreat

Approx 5 miles away in Yulan:

172 Airport Road

Yulan, New York

Bed & Breakfasts

Mountain View Resort

Approx 5 miles away in Glen Spey:

369 High Road

Glen Spey, New York

Highland Lake Camping & RV, Cottages, Rentals and Lodges / Ranches

Photograph of Koinonia Family Camp, Highland Lake

Listing updated 2026

Campsite / RV Parks

Koinonia Family Camp

Koinonia is a place to experience joy, peace, beauty, the richness of faith-filled community and a chance to discover life anew. Grounded in the Lutheran understanding of Christian faith, Koinonia welcomes everyone..

165 Lakeview Drive Road

Highland Lake, New York

Cottages

Mohican Lake Resort

Approx 3 miles away in Glen Spey:

97 Leers Road

Glen Spey, New York

Cottages

Blue Heron Lakehouse

Approx 4 miles away in Yulan:

62 Washington Lake Road

Yulan, New York

Booking.com