Places to stay in West Islip, New York

West Islip is a hamlet and CDP, located in Suffolk County, New York. Local dining options include Clam & Oyster Bar, Joe Michael's Steakhouse, The Brixton, and Horace & Sylvia's Publick House.

If you are travelling in the area, West Islip is located close to Penny Island, Calvary Lutheran Church, East Northport School (historical), Bethpage Friends Meetinghouse Church and Huntington Intermediate School.

The center of West Islip ( which is at is longitude -73°18'20.16 and latitude 40°42'23.76 ) is located 3 miles away from West Babylon, 4 miles away from Bay Shore, 4 miles away from Lindenhurst and 6 miles away from Copiague.

Available West Islip lodging

We currently have 4 accommodations in and around West Islip.

West Islip Hotels, Motels, Resorts, B&Bs and Extended Stay

Photograph of Super 8, Lindenhurst
Listing updated 2026
Hotels

Super 8

Approx 4 miles away in Lindenhurst:

Enjoy free breakfast, WiFi, and spacious rooms at Super 8 by Wyndham Lindenhurst, situated half a mile from Seaside 3 Marina and 13 miles from Northwell Health® at Jones Beach Theater.
134 Montauk Highway
Lindenhurst, New York
Photograph of Travelodge, Bay Shore
Listing updated 2026
Hotels

Travelodge

Approx 5 miles away in Bay Shore:

We invite you to stay at our Travelodge Bay Shore Long Island hotel. Whether you're here to enjoy seaside delights or to visit loved ones at nearby Southside Hospital, know that our hospitality and range of amenities will keep you satisfied. Long Island MacArthur Airport (ISP), John F.
501 East Main Street
Bay Shore, New York
Hotels

Sunrise Inn

Approx 3 miles away in West Babylon:

570 Sunrise Highway
West Babylon, New York

West Islip Camping & RV, Cottages, Rentals and Lodges / Ranches

State Of Ny Heckscher State Park

Campsite / RV Park

Approx 2 miles away in Babylon:

Po Box 247
Babylon, New York
Booking.com

Other useful links:

Things to see and do, places to eat in West Islip

Horace & Sylvia's Publick House ( Dining / Steak ). Located at 100 Deer Park Avenue, Babylon, 2 miles from the center of West Islip. Here at Horace & Sylvia’s we serve a wonderful array of American inspired dishes. We change our menu seasonally which allows us to use only the finest and freshest Long Island ingredients but don’t worry, we still have some of our favorite dishes all year round. We offers 24 amazing tap beers as well as monthly beer dinner events. Our executive chef creates a wonderful four course menu that is served and paired with four exceptional beers. horaceandsylvia.com Link

Carriage House ( Dining / Steak ). Located at 21 Fire Island Avenue, Babylon, 2 miles from the center of West Islip. Established in 2003 in an actual carriage house built just after the Civil War, BCH is rapidly becoming known across Long Island for its unique combination of authentic history, lavish renovation, relaxed atmosphere, stellar service, lively entertainment and superb cuisine that fits a variety of tastes and moods.