Places to stay in Shinnecock Reservation, New York

Shinnecock Reservation is an Indian reservation for members of the Shinnecock Indian Nation in the town of Southampton in Suffolk County, New York. It lies on the east side of Shinnecock Bay on southeastern Long Island, near Tuckahoe, Shinnecock Hills, and the village of Southampton. Local dining options include La Pizzaiola Inc, Apron Cafe, Greek Bites Grill, and Plaza Cafe.

If you are travelling in the area, Shinnecock Reservation is located close to Reedy Island, Old Ice Pond, Haywater Cove, Mill Pond and Saint David African Methodist Episcopal Zion Cemetery.

The center of Shinnecock Reservation ( which is at is longitude -72°25'54.001 and latitude 40°52'27.998 ) is located 3 miles away from Southampton, 5 miles away from Hampton Bays, 8 miles away from East Quogue and 9 miles away from Bridgehampton.

Available Shinnecock Reservation lodging

We currently have 3 accommodations in and around Shinnecock Reservation.

Shinnecock Reservation Hotels, Motels, Resorts, B&Bs and Extended Stay

Photograph of Mr & Mrs Smith White Fences Inn, Watermill
Listing updated 2026
Hotels

Mr & Mrs Smith White Fences Inn

Approx 5 miles away in Watermill:

At bed and breakfast White Fences Inn in the Hamptons, you'll find a classically pretty front porch, friendly owners and a well-behaved resident pooch. This homey stay has five stylish guest rooms and a swimming pool in the garden..
371 Montauk Highway
Watermill, New York
Photograph of Hampton Hamlet Inn, Southampton
Listing updated 2026
Hotels

Hampton Hamlet Inn

Approx 5 miles away in Southampton:

Located in Southampton, the Hamlet Inn offers charming country guest rooms equipped with either a king size bed with a pull-out sofa bed or two full beds. The Hamlet Inn is nestled on 3.5 acres of verdant lawns. Open year round..
300 Montauk Highway
Southampton, New York
Motels

Bel Aire Cove Motel

Approx 5 miles away in Hampton Bays:

20 Shinnecock Road
Hampton Bays, New York

Shinnecock Reservation Camping & RV, Cottages, Rentals and Lodges / Ranches

We currently have no listings available in this category. If you own a relevant property and would like it listed please use the submission form

Booking.com

Other useful links:

Things to see and do, places to eat in Shinnecock Reservation

Photograph of Greek Bites Grill, Southampton
Greek Bites Grill

Greek Bites Grill ( Dining / Specialty ). Located at 1746 County Road 39, Southampton, 2 miles from the center of Shinnecock Reservation. Greek Bites Grill and Cafe is known for serving the finest Greek cuisine and having the best customer service. We strive to create a comforting environment for our guests through lively decorations, music, and our happy-to-serve staff. Our staff members are dedicated to making your dining experience enjoyable, every single time you visit our restaurant. Our strength comes from our skilled staff members. www.greekbitesgrill.com Link