Places to stay in Old Bethpage, New York

Old Bethpage is a hamlet located on Long Island in the Town of Oyster Bay, Nassau County, New York. It is served by the Old Bethpage Post Office, ZIP code 11804. Local restaurants include 317 Main Street, Tristate Seafood, Terry G's Steak & Seafood Grill, and Cara Cara Mexican Grill.

If you are travelling in the area, Old Bethpage is located close to Presbyterian Christian Community Church, Halesite Park, Southeast Elementary School, Wantagh County Park and Jackson Memorial African Methodist Episcopal Church.

The center of Old Bethpage ( which is at is longitude -73°27'15.109 and latitude 40°45'22.194 ) is located 2 miles away from Plainview, 2 miles away from Bethpage, 2 miles away from Farmingdale and 4 miles away from Melville.

Available Old Bethpage lodging

We currently have 7 accommodations in and around Old Bethpage.

Old Bethpage Hotels, Motels, Resorts, B&Bs and Extended Stay

Listing updated 2024

Hotels

Days Inn

★★★★

Approx 3 miles away in Hicksville:

Conveniently located off I-495, Days Inn Hicksville Long Island hotel is the perfect starting place for your adventures in New York. Explore Long Island attractions or enjoy our many amenities..

"We came from Baltimore to attend a funeral. We stayed at a motel one night so as not to have to drive 5 hours each way in one day. The motel was cosmetically unattractive, but as noted above the room ..... "

828 South Oyster Bay Road I-495

Hicksville, New York

Motels

Americana Inn

Approx 4 miles away in Farmingdale:

727 Broadhollow Road

Farmingdale, New York

Motels

Able Management Group Inc

Approx 3 miles away in Plainview:

150 Express Street

Plainview, New York

Old Bethpage Camping & RV, Cottages, Rentals and Lodges / Ranches

Campsite / RV Parks

Summer Adventures Day Camp

Approx 5 miles away in Jericho:

Directions: Traveling east on the Long Island Expressway exit at 66 (Sills Road) make a left turn and then take the first right and proceed to camp. Traveling west on Long Island Expressway exit at 67 (Yaphank Road), make a right at the traffic light, and then an immediate left.

33 South Service Road

Jericho, New York

Campsite / RV Parks

Battle Row Campground

Comprising 44 acres of campground and dense woods, Battle Row is an ideal place to relax with family and friends.

Claremont Road

Old Bethpage, New York

Campsite / RV Parks

Henry Kaufman Campgrounds

Approx 5 miles away in Wyandanch:

75 Colonial Springs Road

Wyandanch, New York

George's Park Av Brake

Campsite / RV Park

Approx 4 miles away in Hicksville:

325 Jerusalem Avenue # 2

Hicksville, New York

Booking.com

Things to see and do, places to eat in Old Bethpage

Mangoes Mexican Bar & Grill

Social Play Haus ( Dining / Other ). Located at 200 Express Street, Plainview, 3 miles from the center of Old Bethpage. Our full café offers handcrafted lattes and espresso drinks. Try our haus blend locally roasted from our friends at Mongos of Syosset! Our menu features fresh & healthy fare for dine-in in and grab-n-go options for those on the run. Our most popular items include Avocado Toast with burrata, goat cheese flatbread with fig jam and caramelized onions and our Mike’s hot honey sandwich. We also have kid favorites to indulge any picky eater including all-white meat chicken nuggets, mac and cheese bites, french toast sticks, and other small fare! We are mindful of food allergies and aversions so our menu reflects dairy-free, nut-free, gluten-free and vegan options. www.socialplayhaus.com Link

Mangoes Mexican Bar & Grill ( Dining / Mexican ). Located at 401 Central Avenue, Bethpage, 2 miles from the center of Old Bethpage. At Mangoes Mexican Bar & Grill, you receive the kind of quality and service you expect from a leader. Our company is always evolving as the needs or our customers change and as new opportunities are created in the market. You can rest assured that, working with Mangoes Mexican Bar & Grill, you will enjoy the latest services, technology and developments in the industry. mangosmexican.com Link