Hotels, Motels, Inns, B&B's, Resorts And Extended Stay in Fair Haven, New York

There are 2 properties listed under Hotels, Motels and Extended Stay Suites in Fair Haven available. We also have 2 alternate listings available in nearby towns. All distances are from the center of Fair Haven, so actual travel times may vary.


Located 1 mile from the center of Fair Haven. Bring your family and friends and come enjoy the Pleasant Beach Hotel overlooking Little Sodus Bay, just two nautical miles from the waters of Lake Ontario and walking distance to the village.
14477 Fancher Avenue
Fair Haven, New York
Bed & Breakfast
Located 2 miles from the center of Fair Haven. Anchor Resort is located on the southwest end of Little Sodus Bay, in the village of Fair Haven. Our lodging units include 4 unique cottages and 4 double wide modular homes. We also offer an oversize brick Victorian house on our property, which is available for rent by the week.
14424 West Bay Road
Fair Haven, New York

Pick from 2 Fair Haven alternatives

Approx 4 miles away in Red Creek:

We invite you to stay with us, we’re minutes away from The Sterling Renaissance Festival, Fair Haven, Fair Haven Beach State Park, Little Sodus Bay, many wineries, cideries and lavender festivals.
13615 Mixer Road
Red Creek, New York
Bed & Breakfast

Approx 4 miles away in Sterling:

1275 State Route 104A
Sterling, New York

Not the town you are looking for? Try our Town Search, or use the Advanced Google Search above.

Nearby towns: