Places to stay in Fair Haven, New York

Fair Haven is a village in Cayuga County, New York. Places to eat in the region include Fly By Night Cookie Co, Giuseppe’s Sub & Pizza Shop, Brandon’s Pub & Grille, and O'connors Main Street Pub.

If you are travelling in the area, Fair Haven is located close to Duck Lake, Enchantment Acres Flower Farm, Red Creek Junior-Senior High School, Little Sodus Creek and Leavenworth Middle School.

The center of Fair Haven ( which is at is longitude -76°42'7.5599 and latitude 43°19'32.88 ) is located 3 miles away from Sterling and 6 miles away from Red Creek.

Available Fair Haven lodging

We currently have 14 accommodations in and around Fair Haven.

Fair Haven Hotels, Motels, Resorts, B&Bs and Extended Stay

Hotels

Pleasant Beach Hotel

For 100 years the Pleasant Beach Hotel in Fair Haven, NY has been welcoming visitors to the shores of Little Sodus Bay. Grab your friends and family and come enjoy the Pleasant Beach Hotel situated on Little Sodus Bay just two nautical miles from Lake Ontario in Fair Haven, New York.

14477 Fancher Avenue

Fair Haven, New York

Bed & Breakfasts

Anchor Resort & Marina

Anchor Resort is located on the southwest end of Little Sodus Bay, in the village of Fair Haven. Our lodging units include 4 unique cottages and 4 double wide modular homes. We also offer an oversize brick Victorian house on our property, which is available for rent by the week.

14424 West Bay Road

Fair Haven, New York

Bed & Breakfasts

Black Creek Farm Bed & Breakfast

Approx 4 miles away in Red Creek:

We invite you to stay with us, we’re minutes away from The Sterling Renaissance Festival, Fair Haven, Fair Haven Beach State Park, Little Sodus Bay, many wineries, cideries and lavender festivals.

13615 Mixer Road

Red Creek, New York

Maplegrove Bed & Breakfast

Bed & Breakfast

Approx 4 miles away in Sterling:

1275 State Route 104A

Sterling, New York

Fair Haven Camping & RV, Cottages, Rentals and Lodges / Ranches

Campsite / RV Parks

Wildwood Lakes Campsites

14607 Cayuga Street

Fair Haven, New York

Campsite / RV Parks

Shady Shores Campground

Shady Shores Campground is located on the water's edge of majestic Lake Ontario and Blind Sodus Bay. It consists of 1500 feet of beach frontage. Included at the campsite are water and electrical hookups, a coin-operated laundry, playground and recreation room.

Post Office Box 24

Fair Haven, New York

Cottages

Screwy Louie's Sport Shop

Located in Fair Haven, New York, and now a second location in Oswego, New York, Screwy Louie's Sport Shop has been supplying New York State sportsman with quality products at reasonable prices since 1987. Screwy Louie's Sport Shop carries a full .....

596 Main Street, Route 104

Fair Haven, New York

Campsite / RV Parks

Fair Point Marina & RV Resort

Set on a spectacular peninsula between Lake Ontario and Little Sodus Bay, Fair Point Marina offers unparalleled beauty, wonderful cruising waters for both sailors and power boaters alike and truly attentive, professional and passionate customer .....

14990 West Bay Road

Fair Haven, New York

Cottages

Fantasy Charters

The Affordable Dream.Lake Ontario's Finest Sport Fishing. The word is out, Lake Ontario trout and salmon fishing is going crazy! Record catches of trophy fish are happening every day.

14708 Wildwood Avenue

Fair Haven, New York

Cottages