Places to stay in Eagle Bay, New York

Eagle Bay is a hamlet on Route 28 in the Town of Webb in Herkimer County, New York. Eagle Bay is on the border of the Herkimer and Hamilton counties, and borders Fourth Lake. Places to eat in the region include The Toboggan Inn, The Eagle Bay House, Lanterns, and The Bay Cafe And Market.

If you are travelling in the area, Eagle Bay is located close to Best Western Sunset Inn, Deer Pond, Eighth Lake, Panther Lake and Round Pond.

The center of Eagle Bay ( which is at is longitude -74°49'0.8939 and latitude 43°46'7.5863 ) is located 2 miles away from Inlet and 9 miles away from Raquette Lake.

Available Eagle Bay lodging

We currently have 12 accommodations in and around Eagle Bay.

Eagle Bay Hotels, Motels, Resorts, B&Bs and Extended Stay

Motels

North Woods Inn & Resort

Approx 3 miles away in Old Forge:

Northwoods Inn & Resort is a four-seasons resort nestled in the picturesque Adirondack mountain region.
4920 State Route 28
Old Forge, New York
Bed & Breakfasts

Big Moose Inn

The Big Moose Inn is located on picturesque Big Moose Lake in the central Adirondacks. This peaceful and relaxing setting is a perfect winter getaway that allows you to feel at home without all of the extra stresses of your daily life.
1510 Big Moose Road
Eagle Bay, New York
Motels

The Woods Inn

Approx 2 miles away in Inlet:

The Woods Inn, in Inlet, NY, provides a year-round Adirondack vacation in an historic inn on Fourth Lake in the Adirondacks The Woods Inn offers 24 uniquely different rooms, Adirondack Guide Tents, ADA rooms, a two bedroom lake view cottage, and .....
148 Route 28
Inlet, New York
Bed & Breakfasts

Wayback Inn

Old Forge, New York in the Adirondack Mountains Located in the Central Adirondack Mountains in New York State, Old Forge has been the destination for generations of visitors seeking everything from serenity to adventure. Old Forge is the largest community in historic Town of Webb..
1910 Big Moose Road
Eagle Bay, New York
Bed & Breakfasts

Mary's Rooms

Approx 2 miles away in Inlet:

152 Route 28
Inlet, New York

Eagle Bay Camping & RV, Cottages, Rentals and Lodges / Ranches

Photograph of The Waldheim, Eagle Bay
Listing updated 2026
Cottages

The Waldheim

Established in 1904, The Waldheim is a seasonal Adirondack resort on Big Moose Lake offering the same hospitality by the same family as it did when it opened.
502 Martin Road
Eagle Bay, New York
Cottages

Clayton's Cottages

Approx 4 miles away in Inlet:

Located on the sandy, southern shores of picturesque Sixth Lake, Clayton’s Cottages is nestled between the ridges of Black Bear, Seventh Lake and Woods Mountains. Deep within the Adirondack Forest, Clayton founded and began building this resort in 1936, using the native materials, wood, and stone.
7th Lake Road
Inlet, New York
Campsite / RV Parks

Viking Village-brynilsen

Fourth Lake
Eagle Bay, New York
Cottages

Eagle Bay Village

Rte 28
Eagle Bay, New York
Vacation Rentals

Eagle's Nest

5502 Route 28
Eagle Bay, New York
Cottages

Art's Accommodations

Approx 2 miles away in Inlet:

South Shore Road
Inlet, New York

Approx 1 mile away in Inlet:

#4 Route 28
Inlet, New York
Booking.com

Other useful links: