Places to stay in Cayuga Heights, New York

Cayuga Heights is a village in Tompkins County, New York. Local restaurants include Atrium Cafe, Louie’s Lunch, Franny’s Food Truck, and Goldie’s.

If you are travelling in the area, Cayuga Heights is located close to Muenscher Garden, Skyhook Lodge Airport, Flying High Farm, Beech Hill and Kings Cemetery.

The center of Cayuga Heights ( which is at is longitude -76°29'9.9599 and latitude 42°27'34.2 ) is located 2 miles away from Ithaca, 2 miles away from Lansing, 8 miles away from Brooktondale and 9 miles away from Freeville.

Available Cayuga Heights lodging

We currently have 6 accommodations in and around Cayuga Heights.

Cayuga Heights Hotels, Motels, Resorts, B&Bs and Extended Stay

Photograph of Horizon Village Guest Suites, Ithaca
Listing updated 2026
Hotels

Horizon Village Guest Suites

Approx 4 miles away in Ithaca:

This well-established community with its enviable location proves that you needn’t sacrifice quality when you rent an "Apartment Home” at Horizon Villages. We are a full service rental community. All exterior and interior maintenance is taken care of for you.
One Leslie Drive
Ithaca, New York
Motels

Super 8

★★★★★★★★

Approx 3 miles away in Ithaca:

Save time and money at our Super 8 Ithaca hotel located close to Highway 13 near the southern tip of Cayuga Lake in the Finger Lakes region of New York. We offer comfortable, affordable accommodations whether you are with us just one night, or are planning to stay and enjoy the area..
"The Super 8 in Ithaca was a pleasant surprise. I was a little hesitant as I have not stayed in a hotel of this rating before and did not know what to expect. Upon arrival, the lobby was pretty and ..... "
400 South Meadow
Ithaca, New York
Bed & Breakfasts

Stone Quarry House

Approx 4 miles away in Ithaca:

26 Quarry Road
Ithaca, New York

Cayuga Heights Camping & RV, Cottages, Rentals and Lodges / Ranches

Cottages

Whitetail Crossing Cottages

Approx 5 miles away in Ithaca:

WHITETAIL CROSSING COTTAGES are located on a secluded 52 acre parcel with 944' of lake front on the eastern shore of Cayuga Lake, Town of Lansing, New York. We are just 10 miles from Ithaca and Cornell University.
21 Belvedere Drive
Ithaca, New York
Campsite / RV Parks

Buttermilk Falls State Park

Approx 2 miles away in Ithaca:

Buttermilk Falls State Park takes its name from the foaming cascade formed by Buttermilk Creek as it flows down the steep valley side toward Cayuga Lake. The upper park has a small lake, hiking trails through woodlands and along the gorge and rim, picnic areas and playing fields.
Rte 13S
Ithaca, New York
Cottages

Westhaven House

Approx 4 miles away in Ithaca:

132 Westhaven Road
Ithaca, New York
Booking.com

Other useful links:

Things to see and do, places to eat in Cayuga Heights

Photograph of Fusia Bento Bar, Ithaca
Fusia Bento Bar

Sangam Indian Restaurant ( Dining / Indian ). Located at 424 Eddy Street, Ithaca, 2 miles from the center of Cayuga Heights. A gracious welcome to Sangam. A holy place in India where two rivers, Ganga and Jamuna merge into another. For the young "Sangam" signifies meeting of two hearts, two seperate individuals becoming one. India also signifies another form of "Sangam" - merging of various cultures and traditions, primarily Hindu & Muslim, and becoming a new identity known as "Indian". Taj Mahal, shown here, is a fine example of this "Sangam" where Persian construction techniques were built by Hindu craftsmen. We at "Sangam Restaurant" are proud to present to you the finest of Indian cooking with the hope and expectation of another "Sangam" - the meeting of East & West. Sangam Indian Cuisine has been serving its customer since 1983 with great Indian Foods. We also serve our customer with Beer and Wine. We hope you enjoy the experience of Sangam and welcome your comments. www.sangamindianrestaurant.com Link

Rulloff's Restaurant ( Dining / Other ). Located at 411 College Avenue, Ithaca, 2 miles from the center of Cayuga Heights. Rulloff’s Restaurant and Bar was established in 1977, serving Cornell and Collegetown for more than 30 years. While Rulloff’s is known for its Famous Burger, we also offer an array of other options such as homemade soups, fresh salads, creative pasta dishes, signature sandwiches and array of exquisite dinner entrees. Rulloff’s features an enticing brunch menu from 10 am to 3 pm on Saturdays and Sundays with our award-winning Bloody Mary. During any given night, Rulloff's attracts a bar crowd that leaves only standing room and makes for a festive scene. Whether you're looking for a bite to eat or a great place to hang out with friends, you'll enjoy Rulloff's warm and friendly atmosphere. www.rulloffs.com Link

New Delhi Diamond's Indian Restaurant ( Dining / Indian ). Located at 106 West Green Street, Ithaca, 2 miles from the center of Cayuga Heights. New Delhi Diamond's restaurant opened in 1993 at its current location, 106 Green Street in downtown Ithaca, New York. The restaurant is still owned and operated by the Sekhon family, who are originally from Ludhiana in the Indian state of Punjab. Their ongoing mission has been to offer authentic North Indian cuisine to the Ithaca community. The diverse menu offers a wide variety of vegetarian, chicken, seafood, and lamb dishes. Many of the dishes are prepared in a tandoor, a traditional Indian clay oven. www.newdelhidiamonds.com Link

Fusia Bento Bar ( Dining / Chinese ). Located at 405 College Avenue, Ithaca, 2 miles from the center of Cayuga Heights. Fusia Bento Bar brings an enjoyable and unique dining experience by: incorporating the essence of traditional and modern Asian cuisines, selecting the best quality ingredients, using healthy cooking methods, and paying attention to your taste preferences. fusiabentobar.com Link

Simeon’s On The Commons ( Dining / Other ). Located at 224 East State Street, Ithaca, 2 miles from the center of Cayuga Heights. Located at the busiest corner in Ithaca, a location steeped in history and considered by most Ithacans as the best place in town to eat, drink, relax, and people-watch! www.simeonsithaca.com Link

Lev Kitchen ( Dining / Other ). Located at 222 East State Street, Ithaca, 2 miles from the center of Cayuga Heights. Lev Kitchen is a concept inspired by a Yemeni flatbread called Malawach and the amalgamation of distinctive cuisines and cultures from countries such as Israel, Lebanon and Syria. Malawach is best described as a crispy, flaky flatbread that is about the same thickness as a pancake. If a croissant and pita were to have a baby, Malawach would be the result. levkitchen.com Link