Places to stay in Fair Haven, New Jersey

Fair Haven is a Borough in Monmouth County, New Jersey along the Navesink River. Places to eat in the region include The Raven Tea Room, Restaurant Diomede, Table, and Red Rock Tap And Grill.

If you are travelling in the area, Fair Haven is located close to Neptune Middle School, Saint James Church (historical), Middletown Township Fire Department Station 1 Navesink Hook and Ladder Company 1, Little Silver Rescue Squad and Garrett Hill.

The center of Fair Haven ( which is at is longitude -74°2'11.76 and latitude 40°21'35.28 ) is located 2 miles away from Red Bank, 4 miles away from Atlantic Highlands, 4 miles away from Highlands and 5 miles away from Eatontown.

Available Fair Haven lodging

We currently have 3 accommodations in and around Fair Haven.

Fair Haven Hotels, Motels, Resorts, B&Bs and Extended Stay

Photograph of La Quinta Inn, West Long Branch
Listing updated 2026
Hotels

La Quinta Inn

Approx 5 miles away in West Long Branch:

Our comfortable hotel is also close to shopping and dining at Pier Village, the Monmouth Mall, and the Jersey Shore Premium Outlets. While you're here, enjoy the sights and sounds of the Jersey Shore from Seven Presidents Oceanfront Park, Long Branch Beach, and Asbury Park.
109 Route 36
West Long Branch, New Jersey
Photograph of Leonardo Motel, Leonardo
Listing updated 2026
Motels

Leonardo Motel

Approx 5 miles away in Leonardo:

Located only six miles from the beautiful Sandy Hook beaches, the Leonardo Motel is the ideal location for your beach getaway. As the most competitively priced accommodation in the Sandy Hook area, the Leonardo Motel is your premium choice for the vacation you deserve..
840 Route 36
Leonardo, New Jersey
Motels

Arch Browbar

Approx 4 miles away in Shrewsbury:

1131 Broad Street
Shrewsbury, New Jersey

Fair Haven Camping & RV, Cottages, Rentals and Lodges / Ranches

We currently have no listings available in this category. If you own a relevant property and would like it listed please use the submission form

Booking.com

Other useful links:

Things to see and do, places to eat in Fair Haven

Photograph of Greek Eats, Shrewsbury
Greek Eats

Chetkin Gallery ( Art & Culture / Art Galleries ). Located at 9 Wharf Avenue, Red Bank, 2 miles from the center of Fair Haven. Chetkin Gallery, established in 1987 by Don and Carol Lynn Chetkin, is an International Fine Art Gallery with a special emphasis on Contemporary European painters. The Gallery is located at 9 Wharf Avenue in a charming, historic building in the marina area of Red Bank. The Gallery's selection of internationally renowned painters has evolved from a handful of French artists to about four dozen artists from France, China, England, Italy, Spain, Poland, Russia, Ukraine, Holland, Ireland, and North America. The ambiance of the gallery is Classical Impressionism, Post Impressionism, and Contemporary Impressionism which is displayed on two floors. www.chetkingallery.com Link

San Remo Fine Italian Cuisine ( Dining / Italian ). Located at 37 Newman Springs Road East, Shrewsbury, 3 miles from the center of Fair Haven. San Remo's combination of northern and southern Italian cuisine offers an array of superlative food, both traditional and modern. Creative dishes flow from the kitchen and tantalize your taste buds. www.sanremoitaliana.com Link

Front Street Tratto'ria ( Dining / Italian ). Located at 31 West Front Street, Red Bank, 2 miles from the center of Fair Haven. With more than 27 years of experience serving gourmet pizza, pasta and salads, the Front St. Trattoria has become a staple to Red Bank's downtown dining scene. From it's authentic Italian menu, to its cozy dining room with exposed brick wall and quaint seating, the Front St. Trattoria is an old-time neighborhood favorite all ages have come to enjoy. Bring a bottle of wine, savor a homemade, antipasto, grilled calamari salad, calzone, stuffed pizza or fresh homemade pasta dishes. Don't forget to save room for the made-fresh daily desserts! No matter what your mood, the Front St. Trattoria continues to bring some of the best in Italian dining to downtown Red Bank. www.frontsttrattoria.com Link

Greek Eats ( Dining / Greek ). Located at 89 Newman Springs Road, Shrewsbury, 3 miles from the center of Fair Haven. It started with a passion for the culture and cuisine of the Mediterranean. We thought long and hard about what our customers would want: the freshest responsibly raised ingredients, skillfully prepared with classic culinary techniques and a little American creativity, heightened with traditional Mediterranean spices and flavors. All that with efficient, friendly service and a comfortable atmosphere. gogreekeats.com Link

Monticello At Red Bank ( Dining / Italian ). Located at 69 Broad Street, Red Bank, 2 miles from the center of Fair Haven. Located at 69 Broad St., steps away from the Count Basie Theatre, and a mere two blocks from the Navesink Water Front park. Monticello has been impressing lovers of fine food and impeccable service in a warm and casual atmosphere. www.monticelloatredbank.com Link

Buona Sera Ristorante & Bar ( Dining / Italian ). Located at 50 Maple Avenue, Red Bank, 2 miles from the center of Fair Haven. From intimate corporate gatherings to large wedding parties, Buona Sera has the space and flexibility to meet the needs of your special day. Chef’s tasting menus are available. Wine pairing and personalized menus can be arranged. buona-sera.com Link